June 19, 2020
Second Circuit Nixes Nationwide Class Actions for Discharge Violations
Second Circuit says that later Supreme Court authority did not undermine the appeals court’s prior decision that creditors cannot compel arbitration of discharge violations.
2nd CircuitJune 16, 2020
Ninth Circuit Criticizes the Supreme Court’s Kelly v. Robinson
Discovery sanctions are dischargeable under Section 523(a)(7), even when incorporated into a bar disciplinary suspension.
9th CircuitJune 15, 2020
D.C. Circuit Has Strict Rules for Constitutional Standing in FDCPA Suits
An FDCPA suit raises the question of whether Spokeo will be applied to bankruptcy cases.
D.C. CircuitJune 12, 2020
Fifth Circuit Bans Molina Provisions in Chapter 13 Plans
Court cannot impose a nonstatutory provision on a chapter 13 ‘full payment’ plan that restricts the debtor’s right to modify a confirmed plan.
5th CircuitJune 08, 2020
Eleventh Circuit Holds that a Chapter 13 Plan Alone Can’t Assume a Lease or Contract
In the first court of appeals decision on the topic, the Eleventh Circuit holds that the chapter 13 trustee alone has power to assume a lease or contract.
11th CircuitJune 04, 2020
Ninth Circuit Narrowly Reads Section 506(d) on Voiding Liens After Claim Disallowance
A claim must be disallowed based on the invalidity of the debt before the associated lien can be voided under Section 506(d), the Ninth Circuit ruled in upholding the BAP.
9th CircuitJune 03, 2020
Sixth Circuit Allows Chapter 13 Debtors to Continue Retirement Plan Contributions
Sixth Circuit is the first court of appeals to take sides on a lower court split and opine that continuing to make voluntary contributions to retirement plans is excluded from ‘disposable income.’
6th CircuitJune 01, 2020
District Judge Rejects the Majority’s ‘Gotcha’ Approach to Automatic Abandonment
Sufficiently listing an asset anywhere in the schedules and SOFA will result in abandonment if the asset was not administered by the trustee, Utah district judge holds.
10th Circuit, UtahMay 28, 2020
BAP Didn’t See Barnhill as Prescribing the Date of Transfer from a Retirement Account
The First Circuit BAP evidently believes that a transfer occurred, even though an ordinary check wasn’t cashed.
1st CircuitMay 22, 2020
An Exempt Asset Effectively Loses Its Exemption in Chapter 13
Lower courts are split on whether an exempt asset is included in the calculation of “projected disposable income” in chapter 13.
10th Circuit, Colorado