Judge Blocks Camden Diocese’s Bankruptcy Plan for Sex-Abuse Victims
A bankruptcy judge rejected a sex-abuse compensation plan for the Diocese of Camden, N.J., saying that it would violate the rights of insurance companies on the hook for payment to abuse survivors, Bloomberg News reported. Judge Jerrold Poslusny said that he couldn’t release the Camden diocese from bankruptcy because its plan for compensating hundreds of sex-abuse victims would expose its insurers to paying potentially inflated or fraudulent claims. Camden’s failure to win court approval to exit bankruptcy after nearly three years highlights the growing discord among sex-abuse plaintiffs, insurers and religious organizations in a handful of recent chapter 11 cases stemming from childhood abuse. The Roman Catholic diocese, bankrupted by sex-abuse lawsuits, agreed last year to contribute more than $87 million to compensate over 360 abuse survivors on its way out of chapter 11. The reorganization plan left room for victims to pursue further compensation from insurance companies through litigation once the bankruptcy case ended. Judge Poslusny of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Camden took issue with several aspects of the Camden diocese’s proposed plan, including the appointment of a so-called neutral third party with the power to value each survivor’s sex-abuse claims. He also determined that abuse plaintiffs would have too much influence over the neutral administrator, potentially inflating the value of abuse claims and ultimately the amount of money the trust would pursue from insurance companies.
