J&J Loses Bid to Send Talc Case, Set for First Phila. Trial, to Federal Court
A federal judge has rejected Johnson & Johnson’s efforts to remove to federal court a lawsuit that is set to be the first talc-related case to come before a Philadelphia jury, the Legal Intelligencer reported. U.S. District Judge Mark Kearney of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania on Tuesday remanded the case Kleiner v. Rite Aid to the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, denying arguments from the pharmaceutical giant that the case needed to be sent to bankruptcy court in Delaware. J&J, which has been slammed with verdicts as high as $4.7 billion over its talc products, had argued that indemnifications and shared insurance it has with its talc supplier, Imerys, meant that thousands of talc cases needed to be handled in federal bankruptcy court because, earlier this year, Imerys filed for bankruptcy. Kearney, however, in a 14-page opinion, agreed with the plaintiff, Ellen Kleiner, that her case linking talcum powder to her ovarian cancer was not sufficiently “related to” the pending bankruptcy, since any indemnification enforcement would need to be pursued through separate litigation.
