Skip to main content

Analysis: Pension Fight Comes to a Head in Memphis

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

More than 250 police and firefighters have quit in Memphis and new recruits are proving difficult to attract, after the city opted to end its traditional defined-benefit pension and cycle a portion of retirement benefits for many current employees next year into a 401(k)-style account, the Wall Street Journal reported today. Memphis Mayor A C Wharton, Jr. said that a widening retirement gap in his city left him with “no other option” than to trim guaranteed payments from an existing pool of employees. Obligations soared to $554 million as of Dec. 31, from a surplus of $94.1 million just six years before. The Memphis pension’s investments were pummeled during the financial crisis, with its mid-2008 assets of $2.2 billion plummeting by 18 percent in a year to $1.8 billion. Its funded ratio sunk during that time from 104.5 percent — a surplus of assets — to 79.8 percent. Nearly 675 police officers, out of a uniformed force of about 1,300, took a sick day in early July to protest the proposed cuts. After a wrenching political debate, the City Council voted in December to end a defined-benefit plan common among public employers for more than 40 percent of its 4,100 employees.